An assessment of histone-modification antibody quality

Description

We have tested the specificity and utility of more than 200 antibodies raised against 57 different histone modifications in Drosophila melanogaster, Caenorhabditis elegans and human cells. Although most antibodies performed well, more than 25% failed specificity tests by dot blot or western blot. Among specific antibodies, more than 20% failed in chromatin immunoprecipitation experiments. We advise rigorous testing of histone-modification antibodies before use and provide a website for posting new test results (http://compbio.med.harvard.edu/antibodies/) [Published in Nature Structural & Molecular Biology, 2010]

Targets (62)

Name Target Species Antibodies Validated Species Validations?
W: Western blot validations
D: Dot blot validations
C: ChIP-chip/seq validataions
Passed / Total?
  • Western blot: Pass if the histone band constituted at least 50% of the total nuclear signal, was at least ten-fold more intense than any other single nuclear band, and was at least ten-fold more intense than recombinant, unmodified histone.
  • Dot blot: Pass if at least 75% of the total signal was specific to the cognate peptide.
  • ChIP-chip/seq: Pass if the Pearson correlation is more than 0.8 on any pair of ChIPs performed from independent preparations matched for stage, cell type or biological tissue
CitH3 multiple 1 fruit fly
W100
0 / 1Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2AK5ac multiple 3 fruit fly, human
W3D2C2
4 / 7Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2AK7ac multiple 1 fruit fly
W100
0 / 1Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2AS129ph multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
1 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2B multiple 1 fruit fly
W10C1
1 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2BK120ac multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
2 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2BK15ac multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
2 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2BK16ac multiple 1 fruit fly
W100
0 / 1Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2BK5ac multiple 4 fruit fly, human
W4D3C2
3 / 9Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2BK5me1 multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
1 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H2Bac multiple 1 fruit fly
W100
0 / 1Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3 multiple 4 fruit fly, worm
W40C3
6 / 7Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K14ac multiple 3 fruit fly, human
W3D1C3
4 / 7Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K14acS10ph multiple 1 fruit fly
W10C1
1 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K18ac multiple 4 fruit fly, human, multiple
W4D4C4
11 / 12Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K23ac multiple 1 fruit fly, human
W2D1C2
5 / 5Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K23me2 multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
2 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K27ac multiple 9 fruit fly, human, worm
W9D6C6
14 / 21Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K27me1 multiple 8 human, multiple, worm
W7D8C5
11 / 20Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K27me2 multiple 9 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W6D6C4
5 / 16Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K27me3 multiple 11 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W10D7C8
15 / 25Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K36ac multiple 2 multiple, worm
W1D3C1
3 / 5Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K36me1 multiple 6 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W6D6C3
9 / 15Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K36me2 multiple 6 fruit fly, human, worm
W6D5C4
7 / 15Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K36me3 multiple 8 fruit fly, human, worm
W7D7C8
17 / 22Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K4ac multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
2 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K4me1 multiple 8 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W8D7C8
17 / 23Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K4me2 multiple 8 fruit fly, human, worm
W8D7C6
17 / 21Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K4me3 multiple 10 fruit fly, human, worm
W8D8C9
22 / 25Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K56ac multiple 3 fruit fly, human
W3D2C2
4 / 7Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K79me1 multiple 4 fruit fly, human, worm
W5D4C5
9 / 14Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K79me2 multiple 5 fruit fly, human, worm
W4D4C4
10 / 12Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K79me3 multiple 4 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W3D4C2
4 / 9Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K9ac multiple 7 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W7D4C5
10 / 16Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K9acS10ph multiple 6 fruit fly, multiple
W5D4C2
9 / 11Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K9me1 multiple 9 fruit fly, human, worm
W9D6C7
15 / 22Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K9me2 multiple 11 fruit fly, human, worm
W9D8C8
14 / 25Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3K9me3 multiple 16 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W15D10C10
25 / 35Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R17me2a multiple 5 fruit fly, human
W6D3C1
1 / 10Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R26me2a multiple 1 human
W1D10
0 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R2me1 multiple 1 fruit fly, human
W2D10
0 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R2me2a multiple 3 human
W3D30
3 / 6Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R2me2s multiple 1 human
W1D10
1 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R8me1 multiple 1 human
W1D1C1
1 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3R8me2a multiple 1
0D10
0 / 1Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3S10ph multiple 8 fruit fly, human, worm
W8D4C2
7 / 14Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3S28ph multiple 5 fruit fly, worm
W50C2
3 / 7Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H3T11ph multiple 2 human
W2D2C1
3 / 5Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4 multiple 3 fruit fly, worm
W20C1
3 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K12ac multiple 3 fruit fly, human
W3D2C3
5 / 8Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K16ac multiple 8 fruit fly, multiple, worm
W5D5C3
8 / 13Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K20me1 multiple 9 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W7D8C4
17 / 19Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K20me2 multiple 3 fruit fly, worm
W2D10
2 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K20me3 multiple 11 fruit fly, human, multiple, worm
W11D7C4
3 / 22Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K5ac multiple 2 fruit fly, human
W3D2C3
7 / 8Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K8ac multiple 4 fruit fly, human, worm
W2D4C3
8 / 9Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4K91ac multiple 2 fruit fly, human
W2D1C1
2 / 4Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4R3me1 multiple 1 human
W1D10
1 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4R3me2 multiple 2 fruit fly
W200
0 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4R3me2a multiple 1 human
W1D10
0 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4R3me2s multiple 1 human
W1D10
1 / 2Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4
H4ac4 multiple 2 fruit fly, worm
W10C2
3 / 3Chart?chs=36x36&cht=p&chco=008000|eeeeee&chf=bg,s,ffffff00&chp=4